When working with independent contractors, one of the most important tax compliance steps is ensuring that payments are reported on the correct IRS form. This is especially crucial when the contractor is a non-U.S. person. Misclassification can lead to significant penalties, withholding issues, and IRS scrutiny.
Let’s break down the differences between Form 1042-S and Form 1099, and how to properly classify payments to foreign contractors.
Form 1099-NEC: For U.S. Contractors
Form 1099-NEC is used to report non-employee compensation (typically $600 or more per year) paid to:
-
U.S. citizens,
-
U.S. resident aliens,
-
U.S. partnerships or corporations (in some cases).
If your contractor provides you with a Form W-9, certifying U.S. tax residency, you’ll likely issue them a 1099-NEC.
Form 1042-S: For Foreign Contractors
Form 1042-S is required when you pay income to a nonresident alien or foreign entity and that income is subject to U.S. withholding tax (even if reduced to 0% by a tax treaty). This includes:
-
Independent contractor services performed in the U.S. by a foreign individual,
-
Royalties, interest, dividends, rents, and other FDAP income,
-
Scholarships and grants to nonresident aliens.
If the individual provides a Form W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E, or similar, this is a strong indicator they are foreign and subject to Form 1042-S reporting, not 1099.
Key Classification Questions
To determine whether to issue a 1099 or 1042-S, ask:
-
Where is the contractor performing the work?
-
U.S.-sourced services by a foreign person = 1042-S
-
Foreign-sourced services by a foreign person = No reporting or withholding
-
Any services by a U.S. person = 1099
-
-
What form did they submit?
-
W-9 → U.S. person → File 1099
-
W-8BEN / W-8BEN-E / W-8ECI → Foreign person → File 1042-S (if U.S. sourced)
-
-
Is withholding required?
-
Payments to foreign contractors for U.S. services are generally subject to 30% withholding, unless reduced by a tax treaty (via a valid W-8BEN claim).
-
Examples
| Scenario | Correct Form |
|---|---|
| Foreign contractor performs design work remotely from France | No U.S. form required (foreign-sourced income) |
| Foreign contractor performs consulting services while physically in the U.S. | 1042-S |
| U.S. citizen living abroad performs software development | 1099-NEC |
| Foreign individual receives royalty income from a U.S. company | 1042-S |
| U.S. LLC receives payment for services | 1099 (if not C-corp and no W-9 exemption) |
Common Mistakes to Avoid
-
Assuming a foreign contractor doesn’t need a form: If services are performed in the U.S., a 1042-S may be required even if the person is abroad part-time.
-
Issuing a 1099 to a foreign person: This is incorrect and could lead to backup withholding violations.
-
Ignoring treaty benefits: A valid W-8BEN claiming treaty benefits can reduce withholding and change reporting responsibilities.
Conclusion
When it comes to payments to foreign contractors, correct classification is key. Start by collecting the right forms (W-9 or W-8 series), determine the source of the income, and select either Form 1042-S or Form 1099 accordingly.